Islam, Women and Modernity: Rethinking Rights and Representation in Muslim Societies

Dr. Layla Nasser

The relationship between Islam, women, and modernity remains one of the most debated subjects in academic and social discourse. While many Western narratives often associate Muslim societies with restrictions on women’s rights, a closer and more contextual understanding reveals a nuanced picture. Islam, as a faith and civilizational system, grants women profound rights relating to education, property ownership, marriage, inheritance, and participation in public life. The real challenge, however, lies not in the teachings of Islam itself but in how these principles have been interpreted, institutionalized, and practiced within various socio-political contexts. The divergence between scriptural ideals and cultural realities necessitates a deeper rethinking of women’s rights and representation in Muslim societies through the lens of modernity.

“A woman is not a commodity or a toy of amusement but a real partner to man who has rights of her own and deserves utmost respect.”

Islamic Teachings and Women’s Empowerment

The Qur’an and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) emphasize the dignity, equality, and justice of women as intrinsic parts of Islamic morality. The Qur’an explicitly states that men and women are equal before God in spiritual worth and accountability (Qur’an 33:35). Islam, in its original revelation, was revolutionary for its time — granting women rights to inheritance (Qur’an 4:7), the ability to own property, to seek education, to choose their spouse, and to participate in social and political life.

History offers numerous examples that defy the stereotype of Muslim women as passive figures. Khadijah bint Khuwaylid (R.A), the first wife of the Prophet, was a successful businesswoman and one of the earliest supporters of Islam. Aisha bint Abi Bakr (R.A) was not only a political leader but also one of the foremost scholars and transmitters of Hadith. Fatimah al-Fihri, an Arab woman from Tunisia, founded the world’s oldest continuously operating university, Al-Qarawiyyin, in Fez, Morocco, in 859 CE — centuries before Europe saw similar institutions. Such examples illustrate that Islamic tradition, at its core, upholds women’s empowerment through spiritual equality, intellectual pursuit, and social participation.

Cultural Patriarchy vs. Religious Principles

The discrepancy arises when patriarchal customs overshadow authentic religious teachings. Over centuries, cultural traditions — often predating Islam — merged with religious interpretations, distorting the egalitarian vision Islam proposed. In many Muslim societies, women’s mobility and voices have been curtailed by social norms justified under the banner of religion but rooted in cultural patriarchy.

Modernity, with its accompanying forces of globalization, education, and digital communication, has become a catalyst for change. Muslim women today are redefining gender roles while staying grounded in faith. From parliamentarians in Pakistan such as Benazir Bhutto and Sherry Rehman to entrepreneurs like Lubna Olayan in Saudi Arabia and activists such as Tawakkol Karman of Yemen — women have proven that Islamic identity and modern empowerment can coexist. In education, countries like Indonesia, Malaysia, and Turkey have seen sharp rises in women’s literacy and professional engagement, signaling a transformation within Muslim societies.

Modernity as a Catalyst for Reinterpretation

Modernity is not merely a Western construct but a global phenomenon influencing every society’s evolution. In the Muslim world, it has encouraged introspection — urging scholars, jurists, and policymakers to reconcile religious principles with contemporary realities. Modern Muslim thinkers such as Amina Wadud, Fatima Mernissi, and Asma Barlas have contributed to feminist exegesis (tafsir) of the Qur’an, emphasizing contextual interpretation rather than rigid literalism. Their scholarship argues that the early spirit of Islam was inclusive and egalitarian, and any inequality today results from historical misreadings rather than divine intent.

Modernity has also widened women’s access to education, technology, and economic participation. Through digital platforms, Muslim women are creating new spaces for discourse, identity, and activism. Online campaigns such as #MosqueMeToo and Muslim Girl have brought to light the voices of women demanding justice, respect, and representation within Islamic and global frameworks. These platforms allow Muslim women to challenge misperceptions while asserting their agency as active participants in shaping modern Muslim identity.

“Let a woman have her place because as you provide the foundation for her, she provides a foundation for you. And through that vulnerability comes strength.” — Shemar Moore

Representation and Stereotypes

A major challenge confronting Muslim woman is representation — both within their societies and in global narratives. The international media often portrays Muslim women as oppressed, voiceless, or submissive figures in need of liberation from their faith. This one-dimensional portrayal ignores the diversity of Muslim women’s experiences across continents, classes, and cultures. A hijab-clad engineer in Malaysia, a teacher in Egypt, a human rights lawyer in Pakistan, and a parliamentarian in Tunisia all embody unique forms of empowerment that challenge reductionist Western narratives.

Within Muslim societies themselves, women still face underrepresentation in leadership roles. Despite gradual progress, political participation and decision-making remain limited in many countries due to structural barriers and societal attitudes. However, encouraging trends are visible: in Tunisia, women hold over 30% of parliamentary seats; in Bangladesh, women have twice served as prime ministers; and in Saudi Arabia, women have been appointed to the Shura Council and permitted to drive and engage in business independently since 2018. These developments show that reforms inspired by both Islamic ethics and modern pragmatism can yield meaningful progress.

Authentic representation also demands reform in media narratives within Muslim-majority societies. Local media often reinforce traditional gender stereotypes, depicting women in domestic rather than leadership roles. The rise of women-led journalism, social media activism, and female filmmakers is slowly transforming these portrayals, offering more balanced and empowering images of Muslim women.

Revisiting Islamic Law and Women’s Rights

The discourse on women’s rights in Islam must be distinguished from political misuse of religious law. The issue is often less about Islam itself and more about how Sharia is interpreted and implemented. Contemporary scholars and reformists advocate ijtihad (independent reasoning) to reinterpret religious sources in light of present-day conditions. Countries such as Morocco, Tunisia, and Indonesia have undertaken significant reforms based on this principle.

For instance, Morocco’s 2004 Moudawana (Family Code) introduced progressive changes in family law, ensuring joint responsibility between spouses and raising the legal marriage age for women. Tunisia has outlawed polygamy since 1956, citing Qur’anic emphasis on justice and equality. Indonesia’s Ulama Council for Women has issued fatwas condemning child marriage and domestic violence, reflecting the adaptability of Islamic jurisprudence. These reforms demonstrate that faith-based frameworks can evolve to uphold gender justice without abandoning religious authenticity.

“Women will only have true equity when men share with them the responsibility of bringing up the next generation.” — Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Faith and Modernity: Complementary, Not Contradictory

Islam, women, and modernity are not inherently in conflict. The perceived tension arises from selective interpretation and politicization of religion. Islam’s essence — built upon justice (adl), equality (musawah), and compassion (rahmah) — aligns with the core ideals of modern human rights. Empowering women is not a departure from Islamic principles; it is a return to them.

By promoting education, legal reform, and inclusive representation, Muslim societies can bridge the gap between faith and modernity. Countries that invest in women’s empowerment — such as the United Arab Emirates, which ranks high on gender equality indices — illustrate that Islam and progress are not mutually exclusive.

As the world moves deeper into an era of digital globalization, Muslim women are increasingly becoming authors of their own stories. Through political leadership, scholarship, entrepreneurship, and activism, they are proving that tradition and modernity can coexist harmoniously.

The task ahead is to preserve the spiritual and moral integrity of Islam while embracing the transformative spirit of modernity — a balance that honors both heritage and progress. Rethinking rights and representation are not about reforming religion but about rediscovering its true essence — one that champions justice, equality, and respect for all humanity.

Read More: The Legend of the Warrior Nation: Afghanistan’s Protracted History of Pillage and Treachery