Cannibalism in Pakistan: A Legal Vacuum Behind One of the Country’s Most Disturbing Criminal Cases
By Hina Azam
Cannibalism, disgusting? Pakistan has witnessed many criminal cases over the years, but few have raised questions as serious as the cannibalism cases reported in Darya Khan, a town in Bhakkar District of Punjab. This incident, which first came to public attention in 2011 and resurfaced in 2014, drew international media attention.
This case involved two brothers, Mohammad Arif Ali and Mohammad Farman Ali, who were arrested in April 2011 after police discovered evidence that they had dug up graves and consumed human flesh. According to contemporary news reports, the discovery involved the remains of a woman who had recently been buried. The brothers were later arrested, convicted, and sentenced to two years in prison, with a Rs. 50,000 fine each, according to reports published at the time.
In April 2014, police once again raided their residence after receiving complaints from neighbours. This time, investigators discovered the remains of a young child who had been buried in a nearby graveyard. Police arrested one brother immediately, and later apprehended the other. The incident brought the brothers back into the national spotlight. In June 2014, an AntiTerrorism Court sentenced both brothers to 12 years of imprisonment each. Their prosecution just involved offences relating to the desecration of graves, destruction of property and spreading fear.
The Legal Void
Now, what actually is the creepiest thing about all that? It’s not the consumption of human flesh , it’s not the disrespect of the dead and not even the murder. It’s actually that there is not a single law against cannibalism till now.
In Pakistan, where burial traditions and respect for the deceased hold considerable religious and cultural importance, disturbing a grave is particularly offensive. When that expectation is violated, the consequences extend beyond the immediate criminal incident. The psychological dimension cannot be ignored. Though it would be incorrect to automatically classify every person involved in cannibalistic behaviour as mentally ill.
Section 297 of the Pakistan Penal Code, 1860, provides protection against the desecration of burial places and indignity towards human corpses. However, its failure to explicitly address cannibalism raises questions about the adequacy of Pakistan’s existing criminal legislation. The Bhakkar incidents exposed the need to examine whether existing legal provisions are sufficient to address such extraordinary criminal conduct.
The Bhakkar incidents were not simply isolated criminal events. The recurrence of similar allegations involving the same individuals, even after imprisonment, exposed serious questions about the effectiveness of Pakistan’s criminal justice response.
The 2018 reports further intensified concerns about whether existing legislation was adequate to address such conduct. The question, therefore, is not merely how such incidents occurred, but why the legal and institutional response struggled to prevent their recurrence. Even after 12 years, no law still exists against this atrocious crime. When those brothers are released, what evidence is there that they will not repeat this grievous offence again?
Many countries, such as Botswana, Nigeria, and the United States-Idaho, have strict laws against this heinous act with explicitly deterrent punishments. Botswana specifically has section 201A, which addresses unlawful consumption of human flesh, body parts and human remains. Section 201 B- cannibalism- makes intentional consumption of human blood or flesh a criminal offence.
These cannibal brothers are released from prison on July 1, 2026. They are completely free now,back in their hometown. These two men are walking free today just because the parliament was too busy to pass a simple law against cannibalism in 15 years.
Are the authorities waiting for another cannibalistic incident to happen? The government’s failure to close such a legal loophole is unacceptable.
We need a proper solution for such atrocities; if this has caught attention, it doesn’t mean that this isn’t happening anymore.
What are the governments actually doing? Why are they reticent about all these abominable acts?
If law cannot protect the dignity of the dead, then what exactly is it protecting? If lawmakers themselves recognised the need for punishments as severe as life imprisonment, what has prevented Pakistan from translating that recognition into effective legislation? This raises a serious question about Pakistan’s legislative system: even after 15 years, there is still no specific law addressing cannibalism. Would the government take responsibility after the Ali brothers are released and repeat this
abominable act again?
Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.