Tobacco-Leaf Purchasing Market Faces Serious Gaps in Farmer Protection Rules
A new IPOR study of 1,200 farmers shows weak compliance with PTB rules, low prices and risky cash deals.
Islamabad – (Staff Reporter/Web Desk) – The tobacco-leaf purchasing market in Pakistan has serious gaps, according to a new study by the Institute for Public Opinion Research (IPOR). The study says many buyers are not following the rules set by the Pakistan Tobacco Board (PTB).
The report is titled Assessment of Tobacco-Leaf Production, Marketing and Purchasing Practices in Pakistan. It surveyed 1,200 tobacco farmers in Swabi, Mardan and Charsadda. The team looked at buying deals, prices, payments and rule compliance.
PTB rules say buyers must follow the government’s weighted average price. This protects farmers from unfair rates. Companies and dealers must also meet their announced buying quotas, including any extra quantity PTB assigns.
The field results show a different picture. About 45% of farmers had no written agreement before planting. Another 52% sold their crop to buyers with whom they had no written deal.
Prices also varied a lot. Farmers selling to multinational companies got PKR 720 per kilogram on average. Other companies paid PKR 559, while dealers paid only PKR 471.
Among farmers who struggled to sell outside formal deals, 85% were offered less than the official PTB price.
Payment methods raised more worries. Among farmers in non-contracted deals, 52% were paid in cash, and 36% were paid on the spot. In many cases, tobacco was bought directly without reaching buying depots.
This creates a parallel grey system outside PTB oversight. It also makes tracking the leaf very hard.
The timing matters. The government is working to stop illicit tobacco trade. Gaps at the start of the supply chain can let tobacco leaf slip into undocumented and illegal channels.
IPOR Executive Director Tariq Junaid said the real problem is weak compliance. He explained that trading outside formal deals through third-party buyers leaves farmers uncertain and at risk of getting less than the PTB price. He called for stronger enforcement of existing rules.
The study also found that 62% of farmers want more purchasing agreements or higher buying quotas from multinational companies. This shows a clear wish for a clear and regulated system.
Junaid added that buyers must be more accountable. He said stronger oversight of quotas and easier access to formal agreements are key to protecting farmers and keeping the market fair.
The main recommendation is simple: follow the current PTB laws more strictly. Better accountability, traceable transactions and a transparent market would protect both farmers and government revenue.
Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.